Welcome to the CSC Q&A.
Get help and give help!
Write great code!
It is our choices... that show what we truly are, far more than our abilities.


+11 votes

In GameStateNode.py, bestAction is never declared in the constructor, so when we try to run MinMaxAIPlayer.py, we are getting "bestAction is not an attribute of GameStateNode" error. Do we need to declare it in the constructor ourselves?

asked in CSC320 by (8 points)

1 Answer

+8 votes
Best answer

Excellent question. If this were Java, then yes, you would need to declare the variable as a member variable (or "field") of the class.

However, since this is Python, you can actually attach new attributes (member variables) to an object at any point, and in any method. In this case, the bestAction attribute should get assigned in the setBestAction() method.

The error you are getting is because the setBestAction() method is not called before getBestAction() gets called.

To fix this, you can simply add this line of code


inside of the MiniMaxAIPlayer.getMaxValue() method.

However, this will always choose to play in column 2, rather than choosing the action appropriately based on which action maximizes the node's value. Still, it will get rid of the error that you are seeing.

(And yes, you could also put something like self.bestAction = -1 into the constructor for GameStateNode, but then you'll get another error that -1 is not a valid column index to play, etc. I thought that leaving the code so that it generates the error would emphasize to students how important it is that the getMaxValue() method must call the setBestAction() method or else the AI won't know where to play.

answered by (15.5k points)
selected by

Nefarious haha. Thanks Dr. Stonedahl!